mielle vs carol's daughter

Mielle Vs Carol’s Daughter Comparison 2024 | Curly Hair Stylist’s Favorite!

Mielle vs Carol’s daughter which is the better hair care brand for low porosity 4c hair? And how do two products from these brands compare.

Dive into the world of natural hair care with our comparison of two beloved brands: Mielle and Carol’s Daughter. On Haireveryday, we pit these industry titans against each other, dissecting their ingredients, effectiveness, and product offerings.

Whether you’re a devoted fan or a curious newcomer, our detailed analysis will help you navigate their unique benefits and decide which brand might be the best fit for your hair care regimen.

Join us as we explore the essence of Mielle and Carol’s Daughter, and crown your personal hair care champion.

Key Takeaways:

  • Ownership: Mielle is black-owned, while Carol’s Daughter is owned by L’Oreal.
  • Product Range: Carol’s Daughter offers a wider range, including body care, while Mielle focuses solely on hair care.
  • Ingredients: Both avoid sulfates but may contain silicones and alcohols.
  • Pricing: Similar, starting around $5 for Carol’s Daughter and $4.66 for Mielle.
  • Hair Milk Comparison: Mielle’s Avocado Hair Milk may suit low porosity hair better.
  • Effectiveness: Mielle may hydrate and define low porosity curls better, while Carol’s Daughter may suit high porosity hair.
  • Effectiveness: Both brands cater to natural hair, but Mielle is better for specific needs like oily scalp.
  • Summary: Both offer quality products, but Mielle may excel for low porosity hair.

Mielle Vs Carol’s Daughter Shampoo

Is it Black-owned?

Out of the two products only Mielle is currently black-owned. Both brands were founded by black women. 

Mielle was created by Michelle Rodriguez and Carol’s Daughter by Lisa Price. The former is still in Michelle’s control and she’s the CEO of the company.

Carol’s Daughter, on the other hand, was bought by L’Oreal in 2014. 

The Range of Products

The difference between Mielle and Carol’s Daughter is that the latter also has products for bath and body care. 

Other than that, both brands have a similar range of hair products. These include shampoos, conditioners, leave-in conditioners, hair masks, styling gels, and detanglers. 

See also  Love Beauty and Planet vs. Maui Moisture Comparison | Which Is Better 2024

The hair milks from both these brands are very popular for natural hair and I have reviewed and compared the two below. 

is carols daughter good for natural hair

Formula and Ingredients

I’ve found that both the brands have a similar ingredients list. Both the brands do not use sulfates in their shampoos. However, some products from both Carol’s Daughter and Mielle make use of silicones, alcohols and perfumes.

You will still find that the brands do not contain parabens, mineral oils, formaldehyde, or other such problematic ingredients. 

I personally liked that the conditioners, hair masks, etc. from both these brands are silicone-free as these ingredients cause a lot of buildup on natural hair.

is mielle good for hair


Both the brands have a very similar price range. The starting prices for the products of these brands are $5 for Carol’s Daughter and $4.66 for Mielle. So there isn’t that much of a disparity. 

The ingredients and formula are also very similar. So you don’t have to worry about getting low quality products for low prices. 

Mielle Avocado Hair Milk Vs Carol’s Daughter Hair Milk Review

I used both the Mielle Avocado Hair Milk and the Carol’s Daughter Hair Milk on my curls to see which of these would be better. I use hair milks instead of the regular hair creams as I have low porosity hair and I feel that lightweight products like these penetrate my curls much easily. 

First off, let’s start with the price of both the products. I ordered both hair milks online and I paid $11.99 for a 8 Fl. Oz bottle of the Carol’s Daughter Hair Milk and $10.99 for the Mielle one. 

As you can see, the price difference between both these products is just negligible. So I’d say you can choose between both these products solely based on the formula and its effect on your hair without worrying about the price. 

Now coming to the hair milks themselves, I used the Carol’s Daughter one first and I instantly could see it work on my frizz. My curls were smoothened and looked so shiny and glossy. 

carol's daughter conditioner

It also gave a good hold to my tresses. But one thing I didn’t quite like about the hair milk was how rich it was. 

See also  Redken vs Aussie 2024 | Which Hair Care Brand is Best For Hair

As I’ve said before I have low porosity hair and I thought this was a bit too heavy for my tresses.

The Carol’s Daughter hair milk consists of ingredients like shea butter and agave nectar which is fantastic for nourishing dry hair and reducing frizz. But it left my hair crunchy as it dried down on it after a few uses. 

I then tried the Mielle Hair Milk (after giving my tresses a good clarifying wash of course!) and I found it much better for my low porosity hair. 

What made me a fan of this particular hair milk is that it has water and aloe vera as base ingredients and then includes lightweight and hydrating components like glycerin and avocado oil that penetrate your hair strands easily.

It also helped add a bit of hold to my curls and helped them gain proper definition. So that was a plus.

So to conclude I’d say that both the Mielle Organics Avocado Moisturizing Hair Milk and the Carol’s Daughter, Hair Milk Original are both very similar products but the Mielle one is better for low porosity or type 3 curls and the Carol’s Daughter hair milk is better for high porosity or type 4 hair

They are also similarly priced and contain a lot of the same ingredients like shea butter, cocoa butter, etc. 

Also both the products contain artificial perfumes so if that’s something you want to avoid you can check out other brands like Love Beauty Planet or Hair Food. 

Why You Should Trust Haireveryday?

The author of this article, Leah Marie Priest has a degree in Cosmetology with years of experience in dealing with hair care, scalp care, and hairstyling. As someone who extensively deals with all kinds of hair textures, products, styling methods and more, hair Leah Marie knows what kind of products and procedures suit each hair type and person. We have also tested these hair products and processes ourselves to provide you an unbiased review about every product. Each of our articles are also reviewed by a team of medical professionals so that you get the most accurate and expert-reviewed information.

FAQS about Mielle Vs Carol’s Daughter

Which Mielle shampoo is best for oily hair?

It can be quite tricky if you have an oily scalp as well as a natural (type 4) hair texture as your strands need a lot of nourishment but your scalp requires less greasiness and more clarifying. So I was glad to find the Mielle Mongongo Oil Exfoliating Shampoo as it’s excellent for oily hair and scalp. 
It’s sulfate-free so it’s gentle but it also contains mild surfactants such as Sodium C14-16 Olefin Sulfonate and Cocamidopropyl Betaine that clarifies and exfoliates scalp. There’s also Sacha Inchi oil and Mongongo oil that nourishes curly natural hair without making it greasy. 

Is Carol’s Daughter good for natural hair?

Yes, of course! Carol’s Daughter is one of the few brands that caters to curly and natural hair types. The ingredients used in Carol’s Daughter’s products such as coconut milk, shea butter, cocoa butter are all highly beneficial to natural hair and what’s more is that they are all Curly Girl Method approved! 

Is Mielle black-owned?

Yes Mielle is a black-owned brand. It was started by beauty influencer Monique Rodriguez in 2014 and has remained black-owned since then. In fact, Michelle is the first woman of color to have an investment deal worth 9 figures with Berkshire Partners. I say, more power to her! 

Summary on Mielle Vs Carol’s Daughter Shampoo

To sum it up, both Mielle and Carol’s Daughter are great for natural hair. They have similar formulas and use similar ingredients that have been known to be good for African American hair textures. 

Both the brands have a similar pricing for their products as well. 

The difference is that Carol’s Daughter has a wider range of products while Mielle caters to certain hair afflictions better. 

Also if you have low porosity hair, I have found Mielle products have worked better than Carol’s Daughter for me. 

Also Read:

Biolage vs. TRESemmé

Shea Moisture Vs Aussie Miracle

Nexxus Vs Joico Comparison

Nioxin Vs Olaplex Review

Living Proof Vs OUAI Guide

Scroll to Top